Megan

Try this amazing recipe out at home for simple but elegant surf & turf and it will definitely be a special dinner! Lobster and Filet for two! The lobster butter is soo so good!

Surf & Turf aka Filet and Lobster

Whoa Babes! Filet and Lobster you may be thinking. 1) What’s the occasion? 2) How much did that cost? 3) Why didn’t you just go out? Well to answer your questions…1) No occasion, just needed a steak and lobster night and we figured we might as well do it ourselves! 2) A Lot. 3) We have 3 little kids and we never go out unless it’s Runza. When we want a fancy meal, we pretty much have come to love making it ourselves at home!
I mean, we barely have time to get to Target much less travel across the country so why not splurge on an occasional fancy meal! Plus this is actually a pretty easy meal to put together and it doesn’t take hours to prepare which is so important around our home!!

Surf Time

Oh man, I really didn’t want to put this picture in here but I thought it was important to include it. Seafood-that’s totally me. I love halibut, salmon, swordfish, lobster rolls (who doesn’t?!) etc. etc. My husband on the other hand, was primarily the steak guy when we got married. But now nearly 6 years later (whoa! crazy!) he seems to have moved in a bit towards the middle. He is definitely still on the steak side, but now I can at least see him from my side of the field. 😉 Our last super fancy meal like this was the Filet Oscar which was such a hit as well if you want to check it out! Anyway back to my point, seeing the live lobsters right before we had to cook them was totally not a good feeling. I had this sick “pit in my stomach” kind of feeling and was looking forward to the filet more which totally doesn’t make sense because the same thing happened to the cow that was slaughtered but apparently it’s different when you are killing the animal yourself.

From this…

To This After 15 Minutes of Boiling…

What is Edible

Just in case you are wondering where to start with the lobster after cooking it, here is a quick pic of what parts are edible on a lobster in my opinion. The meat from the lobster tails of course, and also the pinchers but discard the body and head of the lobsters. According to muah, the best meat is in the pinchers! Save that for last if you can still shove any more food down at that point. I was so full by that point that I ate one bite of lobster meat from the pincher…be smart. Be smart!

My husband and I usually have our annual lobster dinner since the trip to Bar Harbor, Maine in 2009 with my family. Pretty sure we paid less for the lobster in Maine but it’s more about reminiscing about how much fun that trip was and how we hope to go back in the next few years! Blueberries galore and lobsters every time you turn around- now that is my kind of living! The Trenton Bridge Lobster Pound was like OMG!! The views, the atmosphere, the trees, I want to experience it all again! ❤️

Turf Time

Okay, for realz there is not much to say here. So, pick up two prime cuts of beef and add a pinch of salt and pepper to each side. Sear it in some butter and garlic for a short 1-2 minutes a side and bake it for 6-8 minutes total. It’s quick, to the point, but dang this nice cut of meat means business. And don’t underestimate the size of filet. A little goes a long way. So good though, don’t ya think!

All Together Now: Time For Some Surf & Turf

What are you waiting for? Make it a special evening and enjoy!! 👌

Simple But Elegant Surf & Turf: Filet and Lobster for Two

3 Scoops of Sugar

Try this amazing recipe out at home for simple but elegant surf & turf and it will definitely be a special dinner! Lobster and Filet for two! The lobster butter is soo so good!

Print Recipe Pin Recipe

Prep Time 25 minutes mins

Cook Time 40 minutes mins

Total Time 1 hour hr 5 minutes mins

Course Main Dish

Ingredients

  

Surf

• 2 Live Lobsters
• 1 lemon cut in half

Turf

• 2- 8 to10 oz filets depending on personal preference and budget!
• 5 garlic cloves or 2 1/2 teaspoons garlic crushed
• 3 tablespoons butter
• Kosher salt and black pepper

Lobster Butter

• 1 cup butter
• 6 garlic cloves or 3 teaspoons garlic crushed
• 1 teaspoon dried tarragon
• 1 teaspoon Kosher salt
• 1 lemon juiced

Instructions

 

Surf

• Bring a large pot (12qt to do 2 lobsters at a time) of salted water to a rolling boil. Squeeze juice of lemon halves into water and place lemon into water. Add live lobsters to boiling water.
• Boil for 15 minutes.
• Transfer lobsters to an ice water bath to stop the cooking process and let sit for 3-5 minutes. Remove from water. Separate lobster tails and 2 pinchers from each lobster and transfer to a plate. Set aside.

Turf

• Preheat oven to 450℉. Bring filets to room temperature and spray with cooking spray. Salt and pepper each side to your liking. In a cast iron skillet, melt butter. Add garlic and cook 2-3 minutes until softened. On medium high heat, sear filets for 1 1/2 minutes per side and promptly remove pan from heat. Bake at 450 for 6-8 minutes depending on thickness of the filets and to your desired doneness. For a safe internal temperature, cook to 145℉.

Lobster Butter

• While preparing surf and turf, start lobster butter at any time. Melt butter on medium-low heat. Add crushed garlic, tarragon, salt, and lemon. Stir occasionally and let heat remain on medium-low. Remove from heat when ready to serve.

Serving

• Arrange lobster and filet on plate and serve with lobster butter. Enjoy my friends!

Related Posts

Filet Oscar